Welcome to Mangino's Pizzeria, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of New Castle, PA, at 106 N Liberty St. This beloved establishment has cultivated a reputation for outstanding food, friendly service, and a family-like atmosphere. As you step through the doors, you can instantly feel the warmth radiating from both the staff and the vibrant surroundings; it's a place where you can truly savor every moment.

When it comes to food, Mangino's Pizzeria shines with authentic Italian fare that transports you straight to the streets of Italy. From their perfectly crafted pizzas to delectable calzones, every bite speaks of quality and care. Diners like Joseph Sallmen rave about the unparalleled taste, particularly praising the harmonious blend of crust, sauce, and cheese, especially when topped with sausage and pepper rings. It's not just pizza here; it's a memory, a favorite that keeps inviting you back.

And let's talk about those party trays! Each tray is a celebration of variety, offering something for everyone. They have gained a legendary status among locals, making family gatherings and celebrations more special. For those in search of a unique experience, Aunt Nessie highlights the innovative presentation of their meatball sub—something different from the ordinary yet packed with flavor and satisfaction.

Mangino's prides itself on freshness, with each dish prepared using top-quality ingredients. Paul Doyle’s feedback reflects this commitment, echoing the sentiments of countless other patrons who return for a consistently great meal. Whether you're stopping in for a quick lunch or enjoying a leisurely dinner, there's something to suit every craving.

What truly sets Mangino's apart, however, is the community it fosters. As Johnny Villani points out, the wonderful people here make every visit feel like coming home. It's more than just a pizzeria; it's a cornerstone of the New Castle community, cherished by many. Their sweet sauce, loved by patrons like Tony Castellano, creates a delightful twist that you might not find elsewhere in the area.

If great Italian cuisine is what you seek, look no further. With so many voices echoing similar praises, Mangino’s stands tall as a must-visit dining destination. Come and indulge in the richness of flavors and the warmth of genuine hospitality. You won’t just leave with a full stomach; you'll leave with a heart full of joy.